With just $1.8million set aside for the major overhaul to disability support, the Government could well be making similar mistakes that it has in the past,
Some people say that the intent behind the Government’s proposal for change is not to the real benefit of disabled people in New Zealand.
Frankly, it’s hard to argue with that. The way the Government choose to take the transformation of disability support will be interesting, but there is going to be losers, and a lot of them in New Zealand’s disabled community.
Calls for total system change have been rife since a report back in 2008. Then, concerns were that the support system restricted people’s choice and control over the supports and structure of their lives.
The proof of similar mistakes occurring again can be seen in a cabinet paper that proposed system transformation to disability support.
The entire project has a total financial investment of $1.8million. But claims that that sum is an investment by Government are also up for scrutiny. According to the cabinet paper, the $1.8million used to fund the system transformation project has been taken from a $3million contingency already established by the Government. That bucket of $3million was set aside for supporting further work and development of Enabling Good Lives.
This move can be seen in a couple of different ways, however. EGL (Enabling Good Lives) is a demonstration project that has been running in Christchurch and throughout the Waikato. If the system transformation works, using principles of EGL, the need for these two demonstrations no longer remains. If it doesn’t, chances are that the demonstrations will be forced to either stop, or continue minus the $1.8million batch of funding, therefore running at a loss of sorts.
Government have made it clear that any system transformation for disability support has to be cost-effective. In other words, make it work with $1.8million and offer little alternative. In the words of Sacha O’Dea from the Ministry of Health, the immediate future is that “everything stays exactly the same”.
The Minister for Disability Issues, Nicky Wagner, says that culture change within the disability support system will be significant. Within the last week, Idea Services (the operating arm of IHC) cut services that will affect 1200 users of disability support. When pressed on the matter, Wagner said that funding has increased across the disability sector.
“Idea Services will take a strength based approach and will focus on community residential and day services”, Wagner said. “In actual fact, funding for Idea Services has increased and this is absolutely in line with the increases that we have had right across the disability sector”, Wagner added.
The cabinet paper shows that an increase in funding has occurred, at a level of 4% over the course of the last ten years. That increase is spent across the Ministries of Health, Social Development, and Education; meaning a small impact at best.
So the question remains, can an overhaul that truly incorporates greater choice and control be a successful one for disabled people in New Zealand? It’s hard to imagine.